Did general haig deserve to be the butcher of the somme
General haig who was a new commander and in charge of the british army was the man who initially came up with the plan which consisted of innocent lives being lost, however he did not regret it, he thought it was a worthy sacrifice which led to the victory of britain. Therefore, in conclusion i feel that sir douglas haig does deserve the tile butcher of the somme, because he caused hundreds of thousands of soldiers to be killed, and only in aid of 60 kilometers. General haig never visited the front line we will write a custom paper sample on was haig the butcher of the somme specifically for you for only $1638 $139/page was the label “the butcher of the somme” a fair description of general haig field marshall haig: ‘the butcher of the somme’ does haig deserve the title ‘the. General sir douglas haig, 1916 offensives under his direction the british army launched a series of mighty offensive against the german lines, the most famous of which were the battles of the somme (1916) and passchendaele (1917. I believe general haig did deserve to be named butcher of the somme for several reasons firstly because of the number of casualties, secondly because of his naivety not to change his tactics and lastly due to the poor planning by haig.
General haig was the general that led the attacks in the battle of somme after the war, he was bitterly criticized for underestimating the germans and people gave him the name butcher of somme does general haig deserve to be called butcher of somme in world war one as for the somme in particular haig did not choose to. General haig's title of 'the butcher of the somme' originated after the first world war, when, due to large number of deaths britain suffered from the war and mostly the somme the british soldiers have said that general haig murdered all of his soldiers on purpose. Haig wasn’t inexcusable with the tragedies that did transpire and the errors of judgement that compounded his command at various points during the war but to bill him as the ‘butcher of the somme’ is a bit heavy handed. 3- general haig was not the only general in charge- haig did not lead the battle of the somme alone he was accompanied by many generals in charge and it is just haig who is remembered most clearly and criticised.
How far does general haig deserve to be known as ‘the butcher of the somme’ the battle of the somme was the most costly battle in terms of casualties every in the history of british military. A simple stone marks the grave of the general who led one of the biggest armies britain had ever sent to war after his death some people blamed haig for the terrible loss of soldiers in the war. Field marshall douglas haig was commander-in-chief in the battle of the somme the bloody battle took place along a 30-kilometre front between the 1st july and the 18th november 1916 by the river somme, in france. To an extent i do think that haig does deserve to be nicknamed ‘butcher of the somme’, as there was ‘futile death due to incompetent leadership’ – there were more men lost on that day than ever before, or since then – but i do think part of the failure, was due to misfortune rather than bad planning.
The somme was an imperative offensive to the british war effort to prevent a french collapse at verdun and break the deadlock in europe it totaled a devastating 420,000 casualties to 620,000 casualties which was a total of 21%-31% of the total british casualties in the great war in a relatively short period of time (less than 5 months)[2. Does haig deserve his nickname the butcher of the somme feild marshall haig was appointed commander of the army on 10th of december 1915, he was fifty-four at the time and he had had a very succesful military career. Sir douglas haig as a general could easily be named a butcher any person in any war could be called a butcher in history ,many men are rightly or wrongly given the same title.
Did general haig deserve to be the butcher of the somme
- General haig the butcher of the somme does field of view marshall haig deserve to be viewed as the stumbler of the somme playing field marshall douglas haig was commander-in-chief in one of the biggest battles score has perpetually seen.
- Order your did haig deserve the title the butcher of the somme paper at affordable prices with livepaperhelpcom does haig deserve the title “the butcher of the somme” by december 115 the war on the western front was stalemate.
- The extra reading i did about haig and somme i can say that haig was not an “uncaring general”, but he hade some mistakes on his career i also blame the people around him who gave him wrong information and one of haig’s major mistakes was that he never visited the somme during the war.
General haig's title of 'the butcher of the somme' originated after the first world war, when, due to large number of casualties britain suffered from the war and mostly the somme the people of britain wanted someone to blame. Did general haig deserve to be the butcher of the somme in june 1914 a serb assassinated franz ferdinand, the heir to the throne of the austrian empire austria decided to take revenge against serbia and invaded. Does general haig deserve the title butcher of the somme does general haig deserve the title 'butcher of the somme'in this essay i will discus whether general haig does general haig deserve the title the butcher butcher of the somme history essay - uk essays | ukessays butcher of the somme history essaytherefore he has been viewed as both 'butcher of the somme however at the beginning of the. 100 years ago marked the turning point in the first world war as sir douglas haig took command and saw haig dubbed “the butcher of the somme” did haig deserve the title of “butcher.